Supplement comparison
5-HTP vs Saffron
Short answer: We found no study on file that gave 5-HTP and Saffron as separate treatments in the same trial, so this is not a head-to-head result: each grade below was set for that supplement on its own. Both have graded results for 4 of the same conditions: depression, obesity, type 2 diabetes and 1 more. 5-HTP's top grade for an improvement there is B (depression); Saffron's top grade for an improvement there is B (depression). A grade rates how strong the evidence is, not how large the effect is, so it does not say which one works better. Prescription options exist too; talk them through with your doctor.
The evidence side by side
- Strong
- Moderate
- Limited
- Very limited
4 conditions where both have graded results with linked studies. Each grade was set for that supplement on its own: a grade on the left was not tested against the grade on the right.
Depression
Depression (Major Depressive Disorder) supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | 5-HTP | Saffron |
|---|---|---|
| Depression Symptoms | Improves · 2 studies | Not graded for this |
| Anxiety Symptoms | Not graded for this | Improves · 5 studies Studied as: Saffron against placebo or antidepressants in adults with depression and anxiety; 3 trials and 2 meta-analyses |
| Appetite | Not graded for this | No clear effect · 1 study Studied as: Not listed: ask a clinician |
Obesity
Overweight (BMI 25-29.9) supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | 5-HTP | Saffron |
|---|---|---|
| Appetite | Improves · 1 study | Not graded for this |
| Weight | Improves · 2 studies | Not graded for this |
| Blood glucose | Not graded for this | Improves · 6 studies |
Type 2 Diabetes
Type 2 Diabetes supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | 5-HTP | Saffron |
|---|---|---|
| Appetite | Improves · 1 study | Not graded for this |
| Anxiety Symptoms | Not graded for this | Improves · 2 studies Studied as: Saffron against placebo for 8 weeks in adults with type 2 diabetes and mild to moderate depression and anxiety, with a meta-analysis in general and clinical populations |
Weight Loss & Maintenance
Weight Loss Maintenance supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | 5-HTP | Saffron |
|---|---|---|
| Appetite | Improves · 1 study | Improves · 1 study Studied as: Saffron stigma extract taken by mouth daily for 8 weeks by overweight women or adults with heart disease, compared with placebo. |
Safety and interactions
For each supplement, our library safety line where we have one, and every reviewed safety item from its page, in full.
5-HTP
- Do not take 5-HTP with SSRIs, SNRIs, tricyclics, MAO inhibitors, triptans, tramadol or other drugs that raise serotonin, because of the risk of serotonin syndrome (serotonin toxicity), which can be life-threatening. A patient on an MAO inhibitor, with no history of bipolar disorder, developed mania after adding a hydroxytryptophan supplement. Get urgent care for agitation, confusion, fever, sweating, shaking or muscle jerks.
- Eosinophilia-myalgia: in one family, a 5-HTP product containing an impurity was linked to one case of the syndrome and two cases of high eosinophil counts; analyses later found 'peak X' contaminants in all eight commercial samples tested, although a 2004 review argued these traces lacked credibility and found no definitive toxicity cases. The Cochrane reviewers said the possible link with this potentially fatal syndrome has not been worked out. See a doctor for severe muscle pain with a rash or swelling.
- Overdose is dangerous: a 44-year-old man who took ten times the label dose of 5-HTP powder developed severe memory loss and confusion with damage to both hippocampi on brain scans. In the headache trial, 4 people on 5-HTP and 3 on placebo stopped because of side effects.
- Its effects in pregnancy and while nursing are unstudied, so leave it out at those times. Depression with thoughts of self-harm needs urgent professional help, not a supplement.
Saffron
- Pregnancy: in a trial of 50 women at 39 to 41 weeks, saffron pills made the cervix readier for labour than placebo within a day, which suggests it can act on the womb. Pregnant women should not take saffron supplements unless their obstetrician or midwife advises it.
- In a one-week safety study of three groups of 10 healthy volunteers, standing blood pressure fell on the higher tablet strength, red cells, haemoglobin and platelets dipped slightly, and sodium, urea and creatinine edged up, all within normal ranges; the published summary reports these as before-and-after changes and gives no test against the placebo group. A toxicology review found no significant toxicity at the doses used in treatment, and a case of anaphylaxis to saffron has been reported; do not take more than the label amount. Ask your doctor before combining saffron with blood pressure medicines or blood thinners, or if you have kidney disease or a bleeding disorder.
- Saffron is not a replacement for treatment of moderate or severe depression. Do not stop or add to antidepressants without your prescriber, and if suicidal thoughts or urges to self-harm appear, seek help the same day. If you have bipolar disorder, talk to your psychiatrist before taking saffron.
Questions
How do 5-HTP and Saffron compare?
We found no study on file that gave 5-HTP and Saffron as separate treatments in the same trial, so this is not a head-to-head result: each grade below was set for that supplement on its own. Both have graded results for 4 of the same conditions: depression, obesity, type 2 diabetes and 1 more. 5-HTP's top grade for an improvement there is B (depression); Saffron's top grade for an improvement there is B (depression). A grade rates how strong the evidence is, not how large the effect is, so it does not say which one works better. Prescription options exist too; talk them through with your doctor.
What have both 5-HTP and Saffron been studied for?
In our database both have graded results for depression, obesity, type 2 diabetes and weight loss & maintenance. Each supplement's own page lists every condition it has been studied for.
Which outcomes were measured for both 5-HTP and Saffron?
Weight Loss & Maintenance: appetite. Each grade was set for that supplement on its own, so the grades sit side by side but do not compare the two in one trial.
Are 5-HTP and Saffron safe?
Each has its own cautions, listed in full on this page under "Safety and interactions" and on each supplement's page. Ask your clinician before starting either if you take medicines, are pregnant or have a long-term condition.