Whey vs Plant Protein: What the Muscle Trials Show for Soy, Pea and Rice, Older Adults and Lactose
Whey and plant protein powders build muscle about equally in trials that gave them to weight-training adults: soy matched whey for muscle and strength (grade B for no clear difference), and pea and rice matched whey in a few small trials (grade C). Non-soy plant proteins gave slightly less muscle than animal protein in 5 pooled trials. Whey contains milk protein and can contain lactose; plant powders have had lead found in testing.
Whey is a protein from milk. Plant protein powders are made from peas, soy, rice, hemp or blends of them. Both are concentrated food proteins; the question is whether the source matters for muscle when total protein is similar.
The short version
- Soy vs whey for muscle and strength with weight training: no clear difference in muscle or strength gains in trials that gave both. Grade B for no clear difference (Messina 2018; Reid-McCann 2025).
- Pea or rice vs whey: a handful of small trials found similar muscle and strength gains. Grade C (Callegari 2026; Moon 2020).
- Plant vs animal protein in general: across 30 trials, animal protein gave slightly more muscle mass, driven by non-soy plant proteins and whole plant-based diets; strength did not differ. Grade B (Reid-McCann 2025).
- Amino acids and digestibility: whey has more essential amino acids than most plant isolates, and soy scores closer to whey than pea or rice. Background fact, measured in the lab (Gorissen 2018; Herreman 2020).
- Older adults: in older people, muscle mass did not differ by protein source in pooled trials. Grade C (Reid-McCann 2025; Li 2021).
| Question (who, compared with what) | What trials found | Size | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Soy vs whey or other animal protein, muscle and strength (weight-training adults, 9 trials, 266 people; 5 vs whey) | No difference between groups | Similar gains | B, no clear difference |
| Soy vs milk protein, muscle mass (17 trials) | No difference | SMD -0.02 | B, no clear difference |
| Non-soy plant protein vs animal protein, muscle mass (5 trials) | Less muscle with plant | SMD -0.58 | C |
| Plant vs animal protein, strength (14 trials) | No difference | Not significant | B, no clear difference |
| Older adults, whey vs soy vs blend vs usual diet (123 people with low muscle, 6 months) | All three powders kept muscle; no difference among them | Similar | C |
Is whey better than plant protein for building muscle?
For soy, grade B for no clear difference; for other plant proteins, the evidence is thinner. A 2018 meta-analysis pooled 9 weight-training trials (266 people), 5 of which compared whey with soy: strength rose with both, and neither lean mass nor strength differed between soy and whey or other animal proteins (Messina 2018). In a 12-week trial in untrained young adults (48 of 61 finished), whey and soy powders matched for leucine, an amino acid that switches on muscle building, gave similar gains in lean mass and leg strength, with no significant difference (Lynch 2020).
The largest review, of 43 trials (30 pooled for muscle mass), compared plant with animal protein of any kind, including whole diets. Plant protein left slightly less muscle overall (standardised mean difference -0.20). The gap came from non-soy plant proteins such as rice, chia, oat and potato (5 trials) and whole plant-based diets (7 trials); soy and milk protein did not differ (17 trials), and strength did not differ (14 trials) (Reid-McCann 2025). An earlier review of 16 pooled trials also found no difference in absolute lean mass or strength, but a small edge for animal protein in percent lean mass and in adults under 50 (0.41 kg) (Lim 2021).
Is pea protein as good as whey?
Grade C: similar in a few small trials. A 2026 meta-analysis of 5 trials in untrained adults starting weight training found soy- and pea-based powders and whey all improved lean mass and body fat, with no significant difference between them; the authors warned the trials were few and the confidence intervals wide (Callegari 2026). In sedentary adults doing weekly resistance training for 84 days, strength and muscle changes did not differ between pea and whey; the pea-protein maker funded the trial and employed three authors (Singh 2024).
Muscle damage is the one place whey has sometimes done better. In 92 men after hard eccentric (lowering) exercise, whey reduced blood markers of muscle damage against water, pea had an in-between effect, and whey and pea did not differ significantly; scientists from the company that funded it helped design the study (Nieman 2020). In 47 active adults over 60 who walked 20 to 30 km, whey lowered a muscle-damage marker the next day more than pea or placebo, with no difference in strength or soreness (Spoelder 2023).
Is rice protein as good as whey?
Grade C: one small trial found no difference. In 24 resistance-trained men, 8 weeks of rice or whey protein concentrate gave similar changes in lean mass, fat mass and strength; one author holds a related patent (Moon 2020). Rice was among the non-soy plant proteins that gave less muscle than animal protein in the pooled review above (Reid-McCann 2025).
Why might whey have an edge? Amino acids and digestibility
Background fact, not an outcome. A lab analysis found essential amino acids made up 43% of whey protein against 21% to 22% of oat, lupin and wheat isolates; leucine ranged from 5.1% (hemp) to 13.5% (corn) against 9.0% for milk protein, and plant proteins were usually lower in lysine and methionine. Blends of plant proteins came closer to animal profiles (Gorissen 2018). On the digestible indispensable amino acid score (DIAAS), a measure of protein quality, whey and soy rated "high quality", while pea, rice and hemp fell below that bar; the authors work for a plant-protein company (Herreman 2020).
In short-term lab studies of muscle building, a 2026 meta-analysis of 12 studies found animal protein only slightly ahead, with much uncertainty, and a modest advantage only in adults 65 and older (Mendes 2026). Grade C.
Which is better for older adults?
Grade C: no clear difference in muscle mass in trials. In the 2025 review, the plant-animal gap was small and not significant in people 60 and older (standardised mean difference -0.05) (Reid-McCann 2025). In 123 Chinese adults aged 65 to 79 with low muscle mass, whey, soy or a whey-soy blend each kept muscle mass and walking speed steady for 6 months while a no-supplement group declined, with no difference among the three powders (Li 2021). See our healthy muscle aging page and sarcopenia page.
What if I'm lactose intolerant or allergic to milk?
Whey comes from milk. A US digestive-diseases institute lists "protein powders and bars" among foods that may contain lactose and says the words "milk", "lactose" and "whey" on an ingredient list mean "the product contains lactose" (NIDDK). For milk, soy and pea allergy, see the FDA and other statements quoted in the safety section. See our lactose intolerance page.
So which should you choose?
If you tolerate milk, whey has the most trials and the highest essential amino acid content of the powders tested in the lab. If you avoid dairy, soy has the strongest evidence of matching whey for muscle with training; pea and rice have only small trials.
What we'd skip
- Paying for a plant powder because it "builds more muscle": in pooled trials, plant protein did not beat animal protein for muscle mass or strength (Reid-McCann 2025).
- Assuming any plant powder equals whey: non-soy plant proteins gave less muscle than animal protein in 5 pooled trials (Reid-McCann 2025).
Safety and interactions
- Most protein powders and drinks contain whey, a protein in milk that provides all the EAAs [essential amino acids]. The FDA says: 'The major food allergens are milk, eggs, fish, Crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans, and sesame.' and 'People with food allergies should read labels and avoid the foods they are allergic to.' High intakes of protein seem to be quite safe, but there is no benefit to consuming more than recommended amounts. The Food and Nutrition Board has not set a UL for protein, noting that the risk of adverse effects from excess protein from food is very low. However, it advises caution for those obtaining high protein intakes from foods and supplements because of the limited data on their potential adverse effects.
- Protein powders carry risks of their own. Nearly all the plant-based products CR [Consumer Reports] tested had elevated lead levels, but some were particularly concerning. Several recent reports have indicated that certain products are contaminated with heavy metals. For people with kidney disease who are not on dialysis, a diet lower in protein is recommended. Supplements for weight loss, bodybuilding, or an “energy boost” should not be used by people with kidney disease or kidney failure. The major food allergens are milk, eggs, fish, Crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans, and sesame. Nonpriority legume allergies, which include chickpea, pea, lentil, and lupine, are frequently implicated in severe allergic reactions.
- Some people are allergic to soy. Side effects of soy may include bloating, constipation, diarrhea, and nausea. If you take any type of medicine, talk with your health care provider before using soy or other herbal products; some herbs and medicines interact in harmful ways. The use of soy during pregnancy may be unsafe in amounts greater than those commonly found in foods. Talk with your healthcare provider if you’re taking tamoxifen (such as Nolvadex® or Soltamox™). Soy supplements can affect how it works.
- Pregnancy: check any supplement with your midwife or obstetric team first. Breastfeeding? Ask your midwife, doctor or a lactation specialist, who can check what passes into breast milk.
When to see a doctor
- Urgently for swelling of the lips, tongue or throat, trouble breathing, or hives after a protein drink: these can be signs of a serious allergic reaction.
- Soon for ongoing bloating, cramps or diarrhea after whey, which can point to lactose intolerance.
- If you take prescribed medicines, ask your pharmacist before adding a powder. Don't stop a prescribed medicine on your own; ask the prescriber or pharmacist.
FAQ
Is whey or plant protein better for building muscle? With weight training, soy and whey gave similar muscle and strength gains in pooled trials (grade B for no clear difference). Non-soy plant proteins such as rice gave slightly less muscle than animal protein in 5 pooled trials (grade C).
Is pea protein as good as whey? In a few small trials of adults starting weight training, pea and whey gave similar lean mass and strength changes (grade C). Whey lowered a muscle-damage marker more than pea in one of two trials.
Is plant protein better for older adults? Not better, but not clearly worse: in pooled trials of people 60 and older, muscle mass did not differ by protein source (grade C).
Does whey protein have lactose? It can: the US National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases says the word "whey" on an ingredient list means the product contains lactose.
Related pages
- Whey protein · Pea protein · Muscle size and strength · Sarcopenia · Healthy muscle aging
- Guides: body composition · sports performance · kidneys
- Creatine vs whey protein · How we grade evidence
Sources
- Messina M, et al. No Difference Between the Effects of Supplementing With Soy Protein Versus Animal Protein on Gains in Muscle Mass and Strength in Response to Resistance Exercise. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab. 2018. PubMed 29722584 · doi:10.1123/ijsnem.2018-0071
- Reid-McCann RJ, et al. Effect of Plant Versus Animal Protein on Muscle Mass, Strength, Physical Performance, and Sarcopenia: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Nutr Rev. 2025. PubMed 39813010 · doi:10.1093/nutrit/nuae200
- Callegari IOM, et al. Is plant-based protein supplementation as effective as whey protein? A systematic review and meta-analysis in untrained adults undergoing resistance training. J Int Soc Sports Nutr. 2026. PubMed 42954267 · doi:10.1080/15502783.2026.2752317
- Moon JM, et al. Effects of daily 24-gram doses of rice or whey protein on resistance training adaptations in trained males. J Int Soc Sports Nutr. 2020. PubMed 33261645 · doi:10.1186/s12970-020-00394-1
- Gorissen SHM, et al. Protein content and amino acid composition of commercially available plant-based protein isolates. Amino Acids. 2018. PubMed 30167963 · doi:10.1007/s00726-018-2640-5
- Herreman L, et al. Comprehensive overview of the quality of plant- And animal-sourced proteins based on the digestible indispensable amino acid score. Food Sci Nutr. 2020. PubMed 33133540 · doi:10.1002/fsn3.1809
- Li C, et al. Daily Supplementation With Whey, Soy, or Whey-Soy Blended Protein for 6 Months Maintained Lean Muscle Mass and Physical Performance in Older Adults With Low Lean Mass. J Acad Nutr Diet. 2021. PubMed 33612439 · doi:10.1016/j.jand.2021.01.006
- Lynch HM, et al. No Significant Differences in Muscle Growth and Strength Development When Consuming Soy and Whey Protein Supplements Matched for Leucine Following a 12 Week Resistance Training Program in Men and Women: A Randomized Trial. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020. PubMed 32486007 · doi:10.3390/ijerph17113871
- Lim MT, et al. Animal Protein versus Plant Protein in Supporting Lean Mass and Muscle Strength: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Nutrients. 2021. PubMed 33670701 · doi:10.3390/nu13020661
- Singh RG, et al. Efficacy of Pea Protein Supplementation in Combination with a Resistance Training Program on Muscle Performance in a Sedentary Adult Population: A Randomized, Comparator-Controlled, Parallel Clinical Trial. Nutrients. 2024. PubMed 38999765 · doi:10.3390/nu16132017
- Nieman DC, et al. Effects of Whey and Pea Protein Supplementation on Post-Eccentric Exercise Muscle Damage: A Randomized Trial. Nutrients. 2020. PubMed 32784847 · doi:10.3390/nu12082382
- Spoelder M, et al. Supplementation with Whey Protein, but Not Pea Protein, Reduces Muscle Damage Following Long-Distance Walking in Older Adults. Nutrients. 2023. PubMed 36678213 · doi:10.3390/nu15020342
- Mendes BR, et al. Effects of Plant- vs Animal-Based Proteins on Muscle Protein Synthesis: A Systematic Review With Meta-Analysis. J Acad Nutr Diet. 2026. PubMed 42055214 · doi:10.1016/j.jand.2026.156365