Winnowleaf and Examine: a science reference and a protocol tool

Examine and Winnowleaf both look at human research on supplements and other non-drug options, but they are built for different jobs. Examine is a deep science reference written by a large, named research team. Winnowleaf is a protocol tool: look up a condition and get a plain-English plan of what is worth trying, what was studied and didn’t help, and the safety notes.

The short version

TopicExamineWinnowleaf
Built forA research reference: summaries of the evidence, a graded evidence database and a feed of new studies. (source: Examine, “Examine+”, archived 28 February 2026)A protocol tool: start from a condition or goal and get a plan.
Who writes itNamed editors and researchers. Examine says it has more than 30 researchers, half of them full time. (source: Examine, “About us”, archived 1 May 2026)Edited by Seth Pratt, a health coach, not a doctor. Findings are being re-checked against PubMed.
CostFree pages, plus paid Examine+ (Supplement Guides, the Examine Database, the Research Feed) and Examine Clinician Edition. (source: Examine, “About us”, archived 1 May 2026) (source: Examine, “Examine+”, archived 28 February 2026)Free. No account or sign-in.
Track recordFounded in early 2011. (source: Examine, “About us”, archived 1 May 2026)A newer site.

Every fact about Examine on this page comes from Examine's own public pages, as archived by the Internet Archive on the dates in the sources list.

Where Examine is stronger

  • Depth of research summaries. Examine describes its Examine+ Supplement Guides as step-by-step guides covering dose, timing, safety concerns and interactions, and its Research Feed as plain-English summaries of new studies, with reviewers' notes on each study's strengths and weaknesses. (source: Examine, “Examine+”, archived 28 February 2026)
  • A long track record. Examine says it was founded in early 2011. (source: Examine, “About us”, archived 1 May 2026)
  • A named expert team. Its About page lists editors and researchers by name and qualification, including pharmacists, physicians and PhD scientists, and says the research team is contractually obliged to have no conflicts of interest. (source: Examine, “About us”, archived 1 May 2026)
  • A layered editorial process. Examine's editorial policy describes outlining with a reviewer, copyediting, editing and review before publication, and says revisions of its supplement pages are public. (source: Examine, “Editorial Policy”, archived 1 September 2025)
  • No ads, sponsors or affiliations. Examine says its revenue comes from Examine+ and Examine Clinician Edition, and that it does not allow donors, sponsors, consulting clients, advertisements or affiliations. (source: Examine, “About us”, archived 1 May 2026) Winnowleaf has buy links on some pages: buy links to Thorne, Fullscript or iHerb carry our referral, so we may earn a commission at no extra cost to the buyer; evidence grades never depend on it.
  • Clinician tools and a safety checker. Examine offers a Clinician Edition and a Safety Checker that covers supplement-drug interactions, side effects, population precautions and pregnancy and lactation risks. (source: Examine home page, archived 19 October 2026)

What the two have in common

Both focus on non-drug options. Examine says it analyses research to determine which supplements and non-pharmaceutical interventions work, and it covers health conditions and goals as well as supplements. (source: Examine home page, archived 19 October 2026) (source: Examine, “Health Conditions and Goals”, archived 1 April 2026) Both say when the evidence is weak or mixed: Examine's Supplement Guides sort supplements into tiers that include unproven and inadvisable ones. (source: Examine, “Examine+”, archived 28 February 2026)

Where Winnowleaf differs

  • Free, with no account. Every page is open to read. There is no paid plan and no sign-in.
  • Protocols by condition. You start from the problem, not the supplement. Each protocol lists what is worth trying, the amount listed for each pick and the confirmed studies behind it, where there are any.
  • Null results shown as plainly as positives. Pages show where a supplement was studied and didn't help, when the studies found that. A “no effect” finding can carry an A grade when good trials agree that nothing happened (how we grade).
  • Safety on every protocol. Each protocol has a safety section.
  • Integrity checks on the studies. Retracted papers, and papers by authors with research-integrity findings, never support a grade. A finding that rests only on them shows “Under review” and no letter.
  • Findings re-checked against PubMed. We are re-checking every finding against the PubMed abstracts of the studies it cites. A re-checked finding shows “Reviewed” and a date, and each fix goes in the corrections log (what “Reviewed” means).
  • Non-drug options. Protocols are about supplements and other non-drug options; some reviewed pages put diet or exercise first where trials support it. Prescription options exist too; talk them through with your doctor.

Which should you use?

Both, depending on what you need.

  • Use Examine when you want the deepest read of the research on one supplement, a running feed of new studies, or tools built for clinicians, and a paid membership is worth it to you.
  • Use Winnowleaf when you want a free, quick plan for a condition: what is worth trying, what was studied and didn't help, and the safety notes, with links to the studies.
  • Use both when you are weighing a supplement seriously: start from a Winnowleaf protocol, then read Examine's deeper write-up on the supplement you are considering.

Looking at other sites too? Examine alternatives sets out what ConsumerLab, Labdoor, NIH's fact sheets and other evidence sites are built for and what they cost.

Questions

Is Winnowleaf affiliated with Examine?
No. Winnowleaf is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Examine.com Inc.
Is Winnowleaf free?
Yes. Every page on Winnowleaf is free to read, with no account or sign-in.
Is Examine free?
Partly. Examine’s About page (archived 1 May 2026) says the information on its website is freely accessible, and that its revenue comes from paid products: Examine+ and Examine Clinician Edition. Its Examine+ page (archived 28 February 2026) lists the Supplement Guides, the Examine Database and the Research Feed as Examine+ features, with a 7-day free trial.
Which one should I use?
It depends on the job. For a deep read of the research on one supplement, from a named research team, Examine is built for that. For a free, plain-English plan for a condition (what to try, what was studied and didn’t help, and the safety notes), Winnowleaf is built for that. Many people will use both.

Sources

Examine's pages, as archived by the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine (read 12 November 2026):

About Winnowleaf: how we grade evidence, editorial policy and about us.

Winnowleaf is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Examine.com Inc. “Examine” and “Examine+” are names of Examine.com Inc., used here only to identify their service. Examine's products and pages may have changed since the archive dates above.

For education only, not medical advice. Talk to a qualified clinician before starting any supplement. See the medical disclaimer.