Examine alternatives: supplement evidence sites compared
People looking for an alternative to Examine usually want one of four things: product quality tests, free government fact sheets, another graded database, or a plan for a condition. This page sets out what each site says it is built for and what it costs, taken from its own pages as archived by the Internet Archive.
The sites at a glance
| Site | Built for | Cost | Who runs it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Examine | A research reference: supplement guides, a graded evidence database and a feed of new studies. | Free pages, plus paid Examine+ and Examine Clinician Edition. | A company founded in early 2011, with a named team of editors and researchers. (source: Examine, “About us”, archived 1 May 2026) (source: Examine, “Examine+”, archived 28 February 2026) |
| ConsumerLab | Quality testing of products: whether a product has the identity and amount on its label, is free of set contaminants and breaks apart properly. | Membership for its full product reviews; companies can also have products tested for its seal of approval. | ConsumerLab.com, LLC, founded in 1999; it says it has tested more than 7,000 products. (source: ConsumerLab, “About ConsumerLab.com”, archived 31 October 2026) (source: ConsumerLab, “Join”, archived 21 October 2026) |
| Labdoor | Lab tests of products bought at retail, scored for label accuracy, purity and other measures, and ranked. | Free to read. It earns a share of purchases made from its site and sells testing services to companies. | A for-profit company. (source: Labdoor, “About us”, archived 12 October 2026) |
| NIH Office of Dietary Supplements (ODS) | Fact sheets on supplements and their ingredients, for consumers and health professionals, and the Dietary Supplement Label Database. | Free. | The US National Institutes of Health. (source: NIH Office of Dietary Supplements home page, archived 17 October 2026) |
| NCCIH | Scientific research on complementary and integrative health approaches, and pages on what that research shows. | Free. | The US federal government’s lead agency for that research, one of the 27 parts of NIH. (source: NCCIH, “About NCCIH”, archived 30 September 2026) |
| Supplement Science | Ingredient guides, research summaries, head-to-head comparisons and product comparisons with prices. | Not stated on the archived home page, which lists products with their prices. | Not stated on the archived home page. (source: Supplement Science home page, archived 12 October 2026) |
| SupplementDEX | A supplement database for healthcare professionals: a “DEX Score” rating, practitioner summaries and patient-friendly summaries, searchable by condition. | A free start; see its pricing page. | Not stated on the archived home page. (source: SupplementDEX home page, archived 18 September 2026) |
| DoseGrade | A supplement stack builder that gives each pick an A to D evidence grade with study citations. | A free plan and a paid monthly plan. It says it sells no supplements and has no affiliate links. | Not stated on the archived home page. (source: DoseGrade home page, archived 8 June 2026) |
| Winnowleaf | A protocol tool: look up a condition or goal and get a plain-English plan of what is worth trying, what was studied and didn’t help, and the safety notes. | Free, with no account. Some pages carry disclosed buy links. | A newer site with one named editor. |
Each row rests on that site's own archived pages, on the dates in the sources list. Sites change; check the site itself before you pay for anything.
Which one fits what you need?
- To know what is in a product: ConsumerLab and Labdoor test products in a lab. Their results are about a bottle's contents and quality, not whether the supplement works.
- For a free reference on one supplement: NIH's Office of Dietary Supplements publishes fact sheets for consumers and health professionals, and NCCIH covers complementary health approaches.
- For the deepest research write-up on one supplement: Examine, with free pages and paid plans. Our Winnowleaf and Examine comparison sets the two side by side.
- For a graded database or a stack builder: Supplement Science, SupplementDEX and DoseGrade each grade or summarise studies in their own way, with their own scores.
- For a plan for a condition: Winnowleaf's protocols list what is worth trying, what was studied and didn't help, and the safety notes, with links to the studies.
Side-by-side pages
- Winnowleaf and Examine
- Winnowleaf and ConsumerLab: product testing and condition protocols
- Winnowleaf and Labdoor: product rankings and condition protocols
- Winnowleaf and Consensus: an AI research search and condition protocols
- Winnowleaf and Elicit: an AI research assistant and condition protocols
- Winnowleaf and WebMD: a health reference and condition protocols
- Winnowleaf and Healthline: health articles and condition protocols
Where Winnowleaf fits
Winnowleaf is free, with no account. Each protocol starts from a condition or goal, shows null results as plainly as positive ones, and has a safety section. We are re-checking every finding against the PubMed abstracts it cites, and each fix goes in the corrections log. How we grade is on how we grade evidence. Some pages have buy links: buy links to Thorne, Fullscript or iHerb carry our referral, so we may earn a commission at no extra cost to the buyer; evidence grades never depend on it.
Protocols cover diet, exercise, supplements and other non-drug options. Prescription options exist too; talk them through with your doctor.
Questions
- What are the alternatives to Examine?
- It depends on what you want from Examine. For product quality tests, ConsumerLab and Labdoor test what is in the bottle. For free reference fact sheets, NIH's Office of Dietary Supplements and NCCIH publish them. For a plan by condition, Winnowleaf lists what is worth trying, what didn't help and the safety notes. Evidence sites such as Supplement Science, SupplementDEX and DoseGrade grade or summarise studies in their own ways.
- Which of these sites are free?
- NIH's ODS and NCCIH are free, Labdoor's results are free to read, and Winnowleaf is free with no account. Examine has free pages and paid plans, ConsumerLab keeps its full reviews for members, DoseGrade has a free and a paid plan, and SupplementDEX offers a free start with a pricing page, as their archived pages describe.
- How is Winnowleaf different from Examine?
- Examine is a deep science reference; Winnowleaf is a protocol tool by condition. The side-by-side is on our page comparing the two.
- Is Winnowleaf affiliated with any of these sites?
- No. Winnowleaf is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any of them.
Sources
Each site's own pages, as archived by the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine (read 12 November 2026):
- Examine, “About us” (https://examine.com/about/), archived 1 May 2026: https://web.archive.org/web/20260501175805/https://examine.com/about/
- Examine, “Examine+” (https://examine.com/plus/), archived 28 February 2026: https://web.archive.org/web/20260228153556/https://examine.com/plus/
- ConsumerLab, “About ConsumerLab.com” (https://www.consumerlab.com/about/), archived 31 October 2026: https://web.archive.org/web/20261031002120/https://www.consumerlab.com/about/
- ConsumerLab, “Join” (https://www.consumerlab.com/join/), archived 21 October 2026: https://web.archive.org/web/20261021122517/https://www.consumerlab.com/join/
- Labdoor, “About us” (https://labdoor.com/about), archived 12 October 2026: https://web.archive.org/web/20261012070137/https://labdoor.com/about
- NIH Office of Dietary Supplements home page (https://ods.od.nih.gov/), archived 17 October 2026: https://web.archive.org/web/20261017075613/https://ods.od.nih.gov/
- NCCIH, “About NCCIH” (https://www.nccih.nih.gov/about), archived 30 September 2026: https://web.archive.org/web/20260930014154/https://www.nccih.nih.gov/about
- Supplement Science home page (https://supplementscience.ai/), archived 12 October 2026: https://web.archive.org/web/20261012034718/https://supplementscience.ai/
- SupplementDEX home page (https://www.supplementdex.com/), archived 18 September 2026: https://web.archive.org/web/20260918235020/https://www.supplementdex.com/
- DoseGrade home page (https://www.dosegrade.com/), archived 8 June 2026: https://web.archive.org/web/20260608052611/https://www.dosegrade.com/
Winnowleaf is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any site on this page. Examine, ConsumerLab, Labdoor, Supplement Science, SupplementDEX and DoseGrade are names of their owners, used here only to identify their services. ODS and NCCIH are parts of the US National Institutes of Health. Their products, prices and pages may have changed since the archive dates above.
For education only, not medical advice. Talk to a qualified clinician before starting any supplement. See the medical disclaimer.