Supplement comparison
Fish Oil vs Flaxseed
Short answer: One study on file gave Fish Oil and Flaxseed as separate treatments in the same trial (listed below by title); each grade below was still set for that supplement on its own. Both have graded results for 7 of the same conditions: cardiovascular disease, coronary artery disease (CAD), type 2 diabetes and 4 more. Fish Oil's top grade for an improvement there is D (overweight); Flaxseed's top grade for an improvement there is B (cardiovascular disease). A grade rates how strong the evidence is, not how large the effect is, so it does not say which one works better. Prescription options exist too; talk them through with your doctor.
Studies that gave each as a separate treatment
- A comparison of fish oil, flaxseed oil and hempseed oil supplementation on selected parameters of cardiovascular health in healthy volunteers (2008)Studied: 86 healthy men and women, given fish oil, flaxseed oil, hempseed oil or placebo capsules for 12 weeks.
The evidence side by side
- Strong
- Moderate
- Limited
- Very limited
7 conditions where both have graded results with linked studies. Each grade was set for that supplement on its own: a grade on the left was not tested against the grade on the right.
Cardiovascular Disease
Cardiovascular Disease Prevention & Support supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | Fish Oil | Flaxseed |
|---|---|---|
| Cardiovascular Disease Mortality | See studies · 6 studies Studied as: little or no effect on cardiovascular deaths in the largest review (Cochrane 2020: risk ratio 0.92, 0.86 to 0.99; 29 trials; moderate certainty) | Not graded for this |
| All-Cause Mortality | No clear effect · 2 studies | Not graded for this |
| Apolipoprotein A | Not graded for this | Improves · 1 study Studied as: Measured as lipoprotein(a) [Lp(a)], a blood fat particle where lower is better; not apolipoprotein A-I. |
Coronary Artery Disease (CAD)
Ischemic Heart Disease Supportive Care supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | Fish Oil | Flaxseed |
|---|---|---|
| Atrial Fibrillation Incidence | Worsens · 3 studies Studied as: Not listed: ask a clinician | Not graded for this |
| Blood glucose | Not graded for this | Improves · 1 study |
Type 2 Diabetes
Type 2 Diabetes supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | Fish Oil | Flaxseed |
|---|---|---|
| Adiponectin | Mixed effect · 3 studies | Not graded for this |
| Blood glucose | Not graded for this | No effect · 2 studies Studied as: Adults with type 2 diabetes took flaxseed lignan capsules or flaxseed oil by mouth daily for 3 months, against placebo capsules or safflower oil. |
Overweight
Overweight (BMI 25-29.9) supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | Fish Oil | Flaxseed |
|---|---|---|
| Adiponectin | Improves · 3 studies | No clear effect · 2 studies Studied as: Ground flaxseed or flaxseed products by mouth daily for 8-12 weeks |
High Cholesterol
High Cholesterol (Hypercholesterolemia) supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | Fish Oil | Flaxseed |
|---|---|---|
| Adiponectin | No clear effect · 2 studies | Not graded for this |
| Apolipoprotein A | No clear effect · 1 study | Not graded for this |
| Blood glucose | Not graded for this | Improves · 1 study Studied as: Not listed: ask a clinician |
Metabolic Health
Metabolic Syndrome supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | Fish Oil | Flaxseed |
|---|---|---|
| Apolipoprotein A | No clear effect · 2 studies | Not graded for this |
| Adiponectin | Not graded for this | No clear effect · 2 studies Studied as: Ground flaxseed or flaxseed products by mouth daily for 8-12 weeks |
Obesity
Overweight (BMI 25-29.9) supplement stack: doses and evidence
| Outcome | Fish Oil | Flaxseed |
|---|---|---|
| Blood Flow | No clear effect · 1 study | Not graded for this |
| Blood glucose | Not graded for this | Mixed effect · 1 study Studied as: Not listed: ask a clinician |
| Adiponectin | Not graded for this | No clear effect · 2 studies Studied as: Ground flaxseed or flaxseed products by mouth daily for 8-12 weeks |
Safety and interactions
For each supplement, our library safety line where we have one, and every reviewed safety item from its page, in full.
Fish Oil
- Fish oil and heart rhythm and bleeding: pooling seven randomised trials (81,210 people), omega-3 supplements made atrial fibrillation, an irregular heartbeat, more likely (hazard ratio 1.25). The risk was higher even in the four trials that gave 1 g a day or less (58,939 people; hazard ratio 1.12), and higher still in the three heart trials that gave more than 1 g (22,271 patients; hazard ratio 1.49): two used 4 g a day of prescription-strength formulations and the third gave 1.8 g a day to people aged 70 to 82 who had had a heart attack 2 to 8 weeks earlier. In a review of 11 trials (120,643 people), bleeding overall did not differ significantly with omega-3 (rate ratio 1.09), but in the two trials of high-dose purified EPA bleeding was about 50% higher (0.6% more people), and bleeding risk rose with the EPA dose; background antiplatelet use did not explain the extra bleeding across trials. Tell your doctor if you take a blood thinner.
- Heart rhythm: atrial fibrillation, a common irregular heartbeat, became more likely with omega-3 supplements when seven randomised heart trials were pooled (81,210 participants; hazard ratio 1.25). Low doses did not avoid it: in the four trials that kept to 1 g daily or less (together 58,939 participants) the hazard ratio was still 1.12, and it reached 1.49 in the three trials above 1 g (22,271 patients); REDUCE-IT and STRENGTH there gave 4 g daily of prescription-strength products, while OMEMI's patients, aged 70 to 82, took 1.8 g daily, having suffered a heart attack within the previous 2 to 8 weeks. See a doctor about palpitations, breathlessness or dizziness while taking fish oil.
- Bleeding: when 11 trials totalling 120,643 people were reviewed, bleeding overall did not differ significantly with omega-3 (rate ratio 1.09). The exception was high-dose purified EPA, a prescription form rather than ordinary mixed fish oil: in its two trials bleeding ran about 50% above control, an absolute excess of 0.6%, roughly one extra bleed per 166 people treated; risk climbed with the EPA dose, and comparing trials, background antiplatelet drugs did not account for the excess. If you take warfarin, a newer anticoagulant or an antiplatelet drug, or have surgery planned, tell your prescriber or surgeon about the fish oil.
- Pregnancy: pooling 70 trials with 19,927 women, a 2018 Cochrane review of omega-3 from supplements or foods reported fewer births before 37 weeks (11.9% against 13.4%; 26 trials, 10,304 women) but probably made pregnancies longer than 42 weeks more common, rising from 1.6% to 2.6% (6 trials, 5,141 women), with a possible small, non-significant rise in babies large for their gestational age (relative risk 1.15; 6 trials, 3,722 women). In a later Australian trial of 5,517 women given fish oil or vegetable oil capsules, early preterm birth was not reduced (2.2% against 2.0%), more babies were very large for their gestational age (relative risk 1.30), and minor stomach upsets were more common. Agree any fish oil product in pregnancy with your midwife or obstetric team; the separate DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) page goes through the pregnancy trials.
- Very high triglycerides, heart disease and major depression need a doctor's care, and over-the-counter capsules do not replace prescribed treatment. Avoid fish-derived oils if you have a fish allergy.
Results on the Fish Oil page where it made a measure worse, or that record side effects in trials:
- Atrial Fibrillation Incidence (Coronary Artery Disease (CAD)): Worsens (3 studies)
- Low-density lipoprotein (LDL) (Stroke): Worsens (1 study)
- Low-density lipoprotein (LDL) (Type 2 Diabetes): Worsens (1 study)
- Low-density lipoprotein (LDL) (Dyslipidemia): Worsens (2 studies)
- Low-density lipoprotein (LDL) (High Cholesterol): Worsens (2 studies)
Flaxseed
- Don’t eat raw or unripe flaxseeds; they may contain potentially toxic compounds. Higher doses of flaxseed or flaxseed oil supplements may cause uncomfortable digestive symptoms like bloating, fullness, and diarrhea. There are theoretical reasons to suspect that flaxseed or flaxseed oil might interact with other drugs, such as anticoagulant or antiplatelet drugs. If you take any type of medicine, talk with your health care provider before using flaxseed, flaxseed oil, or other herbal products; some herbs and medicines interact in harmful ways. Some studies of the use of flaxseed during pregnancy suggest it is possibly unsafe, but the evidence is not conclusive. Little is known about whether it is safe to use flaxseed oil during pregnancy or while breastfeeding.
- Gut side effects are common: in the hot flash trial, both the flaxseed and placebo groups reported bloating, wind, diarrhoea and nausea, likely from the fibre. Take ground flaxseed with plenty of water, and avoid it if you have a narrowed bowel, a past bowel obstruction or trouble swallowing.
- Flaxseed may lower blood sugar and can lower blood pressure, so if you take diabetes or blood pressure medicines, check with your doctor and monitor your readings when you start. Take other oral medicines at a different time of day from a large fibre dose.
- Lignans in flaxseed act weakly like oestrogen. If you have or have had a hormone-sensitive cancer, talk to your oncology team first: a 2014 systematic review found only 10 studies in breast cancer, just 2 of them randomized trials. Flaxseed does not treat cancer.
- If you are pregnant or breastfeeding, ask your doctor or midwife before taking flaxseed supplements beyond normal food amounts.
Questions
How do Fish Oil and Flaxseed compare?
One study on file gave Fish Oil and Flaxseed as separate treatments in the same trial (listed below by title); each grade below was still set for that supplement on its own. Both have graded results for 7 of the same conditions: cardiovascular disease, coronary artery disease (CAD), type 2 diabetes and 4 more. Fish Oil's top grade for an improvement there is D (overweight); Flaxseed's top grade for an improvement there is B (cardiovascular disease). A grade rates how strong the evidence is, not how large the effect is, so it does not say which one works better. Prescription options exist too; talk them through with your doctor.
What have both Fish Oil and Flaxseed been studied for?
In our database both have graded results for cardiovascular disease, coronary artery disease (CAD), type 2 diabetes, overweight, high cholesterol, metabolic health and obesity. Each supplement's own page lists every condition it has been studied for.
Which outcomes were measured for both Fish Oil and Flaxseed?
Overweight: adiponectin. Each grade was set for that supplement on its own, so the grades sit side by side but do not compare the two in one trial.
Are Fish Oil and Flaxseed safe?
Each has its own cautions, listed in full on this page under "Safety and interactions" and on each supplement's page. Ask your clinician before starting either if you take medicines, are pregnant or have a long-term condition.