Protocol · General Wellness
Antioxidant Status Protocol
No supplement has been shown to improve health by raising blood antioxidant readings, and in a Cochrane review pooling 78 trials, antioxidant supplements did not reduce deaths. The antioxidant status stack includes copper, GlyNAC (glycine with N-acetylcysteine), mitoquinone, piperine (black pepper extract) and cocoa flavanols, all with limited evidence, plus piceatannol, which did not help. Copper raised an antioxidant enzyme without changing heart-health measures. GlyNAC raised glutathione in small trials from one group but not in a 2-week trial of 114 older adults. Mitoquinone lowered markers of oxidative damage in small trials, piperine was tested only with turmeric, and cocoa lowered one damage marker. Extra copper can harm the liver.
Sources: PMID 22419320; PMID 22444781; PMID 35975308; PMID 35821844; PMID 38981985; PMID 38082237; PMID 38925412; PMID 29057795; PMID 22372787
The stack
| Grade | Supplement and why it’s in the stack | Amount listed | Evidence on file | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Limited evidence No supplement here has more than limited evidence | ||||
| – | CopperLimited evidence: in an 8-week trial in healthy adults, 2 mg a day by mouth raised two copper enzymes, including red-cell superoxide dismutase, without changing CRP or cholesterol; other trials found no rise in that enzyme and no change in LDL oxidation
3 confirmed studiesConfirmed studies for Copper (titles as PubMed lists them)
| Amount listed: Adults: 2 mg a day by mouth, as in an 8-week trial. Upper limit for adults: 10 mg a day; above this, copper can harm the liver. Not for people with Wilson disease (source under Safety and when to see a clinician) | Not graded yet | |
| D | GlyNACLimited evidence: in small trials from one research group it raised glutathione in older adults and in people with HIV, but a 2-week trial in 114 healthy older adults found no rise against placebo
3 confirmed studiesConfirmed studies for GlyNAC (titles as PubMed lists them)
| Amount listed: Adults: 2.4–7.2 g a day of glycine and N-acetylcysteine in equal parts, as tested for 2 weeks | Grade D for Oxidative Stress2 studiesReviewed | |
| C | Mitoquinone mesylateLimited evidence: in small trials, 20 mg a day by mouth lowered markers of oxidative damage such as oxidised LDL, but a 12-week trial in older adults found no change in muscle responses to exercise
| Amount listed: Adults: 20 mg a day by mouth, as in 4- to 12-week trials | Grade C for Oxidative Stress3 studiesReviewed | |
| C | PiperineLimited evidence: tested only with turmeric or curcumin, where antioxidant capacity rose in one stroke trial and malondialdehyde fell more than with turmeric alone in people on haemodialysis
2 confirmed studiesConfirmed studies for Piperine (titles as PubMed lists them)
| Amount listed: No trial of piperine on its own, so no amount is suggested. Piperine raises blood levels of some medicines (source under Safety and when to see a clinician) | Grade C for Antioxidant Status2 studiesReviewed | |
| – | FlavanolsLimited evidence: in a review of 33 trials in all of cocoa or dark chocolate, malondialdehyde fell but CRP and most other markers did not change
2 confirmed studiesConfirmed studies for Flavanols (titles as PubMed lists them)
| Amount listed: Studied as cocoa and dark chocolate, not as pills, so no supplement amount is suggested | Not graded yet | |
| – | PiceatannolStudied, didn't help: in an 8-week placebo-controlled trial in 39 adults, oxidative stress markers stayed the same on 20 mg daily
1 confirmed studyConfirmed studies for Piceatannol (titles as PubMed lists them)
| Amount listed: No amount: studied for antioxidant status and did not help | Not graded yet | |
What the evidence says
- Pills did not save lives. Pooling 78 randomised trials with 296,707 participants, who took every antioxidant orally for a median of 2 years, a Cochrane review saw no change in deaths overall (relative risk 1.02). In the 56 lower-bias trials, 12.9% died on antioxidants against 10.6% on control (relative risk 1.04), and in 38 such trials without factorial designs the relative risk was 1.10. In those low-bias trials beta-carotene (26 trials; 1.05) and vitamin E (46 trials; 1.03) increased deaths, vitamin A (12 trials), vitamin C (29) and selenium (17) showed no significant effect, and larger vitamin A doses were tied to higher mortality. Two tiny trials in some of these pools come from a research group whose work has drawn retractions, with almost no weight. The reviewers saw no evidence backing antioxidant supplements for prevention.
- Copper in healthy adults: an enzyme rises, health measures do not. In an 8-week trial in middle-aged volunteers whose cholesterol was moderately raised, red-cell superoxide dismutase and ceruloplasmin, two copper enzymes, rose on 2 mg a day of copper (as copper glycinate) and not on placebo, while CRP, homocysteine and cholesterol did not change significantly; oxidised LDL fell, but inconsistently. In 26 healthy people aged 50 to 70, two of three 6-week courses (3 mg as copper sulphate, 6 mg as copper glycinate) made red cells resist oxidation for longer than after placebo washout, without raising their superoxide dismutase, and in a four-centre European study, LDL's tendency to oxidise was unaffected by up to 6 mg daily.
- GlyNAC: small positive trials from one group, and a null independent trial. In a 16-week trial by one US research group, glutathione and oxidative stress markers improved in 12 older adults given glycine and N-acetylcysteine (100 mg of each per kilogram of body weight daily) and not in 12 given placebo; the results were tested within each group, and no adverse events related to the supplements were reported. The same group reported gains in an open study of 8 people with HIV that faded after they stopped. In a separate randomised trial in 114 healthy older adults, 2.4 to 7.2 g a day for 2 weeks left total glutathione, its main outcome, and the reduced-to-oxidised glutathione ratio no higher than placebo; in a post-hoc analysis, a rise appeared only in participants on the two higher doses who started with high malondialdehyde and low glutathione.
- Mitoquinone: lower damage markers in small trials, little else. Twenty healthy volunteers between 60 and 79 years old whose arteries widened poorly (flow-mediated dilation under 6%), took 20 mg a day for 6 weeks in a crossover trial: widening rose by 42% and oxidised LDL fell against placebo, while inflammation markers did not differ. In 19 trained male cyclists, 28 days of 20 mg a day cut 8 km time-trial times by 1.3%, with lower F2-isoprostanes, a marker of oxidative damage, than placebo after the ride. A 2024 meta-analysis of 8 studies in all (188 people) found less exercise-induced oxidative damage across the six studies with that outcome, though its Egger test suggested publication bias, and no endurance gain across the 5 studies testing it. In a 12-week trial in 22 adults aged 65 to 80, 20 mg a day did not change muscle redox responses to a bout of exercise.
- Piperine has only been studied together with turmeric or curcumin. In 66 people recovering from ischaemic stroke (56 finished), tablets of 500 mg curcumin with 5 mg piperine for 12 weeks raised total antioxidant capacity and lowered high-sensitivity CRP against placebo; a curcumin manufacturer made the tablets, and one of its staff was an author. In people on haemodialysis, 3 g of turmeric with 2 mg of piperine a day for 12 weeks lowered malondialdehyde more than turmeric on its own, with no change in catalase, glutathione reductase or CRP. Because piperine was never given alone, these results belong to the combination.
- Cocoa flavanols and piceatannol. A 2024 review of 33 controlled trials in all (1,379 adults) of cocoa or dark chocolate, with a summary that does not split the trials by marker, found lower malondialdehyde and higher nitric oxide, but no significant change in CRP, IL-6, TNF-alpha or the other markers; the malondialdehyde and CRP results were rated high certainty and the rest very low to moderate, 16 trials did not report independent purity testing, and none mentioned heavy-metal contamination. A diet with 22 g of cocoa powder and 16 g of dark chocolate a day raised blood antioxidant capacity by about 4% in 23 healthy adults, while 2 weeks of high-flavanol dark chocolate did not change LDL oxidation, total antioxidant capacity or 8-isoprostanes in 21. Eight weeks of piceatannol at 20 mg daily left oxidative stress markers unchanged in 39 adults.
Safety and when to see a clinician
- Vitamin E safety: a review of 19 trials (135,967 people) found 39 more deaths per 10,000 people in the 11 trials that used 400 IU a day or more, with the risk rising above about 150 IU a day; 10 of the 19 trials combined vitamin E with other nutrients, and many enrolled people with chronic disease. In the 5 double-blind trials that reported it, vitamin E raised bleeding (haemorrhagic) strokes (relative risk 1.22), about 1 extra per 1,250 people. In the SELECT trial, 400 IU a day raised prostate cancer in relatively healthy men (hazard ratio 1.17), and in HOPE-TOO, 400 IU a day raised heart failure in people with vascular disease or diabetes (relative risk 1.13). Beta-carotene also raised deaths in the Cochrane review's low-bias trials, and bigger vitamin A doses went with more deaths, so avoid high-dose pills of these unless a clinician advises them. A low antioxidant test result is not a diagnosis; persistent tiredness, repeated infections or wounds that heal slowly need a doctor to look for the cause.
- Copper is needed only in small amounts. Adults should stay under 10 mg a day, the upper limit, and people with Wilson disease or liver failure should not take it, because their bodies cannot clear copper into bile. In a 2-month trial of 1,365 healthy adults randomised to water with different copper levels, those drinking 6 mg of copper per litre reported nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea or abdominal pain more often than those whose water held almost none, with no change in liver tests. Swallowing copper sulphate is poisoning: in a series of 35 adult cases, red-cell breakdown affected 68.57%, kidney failure 51.43%, acute hepatitis 45.71% and bleeding from the upper gut 40%, and 22.9% died. Many multivitamins already contain copper, so count every source.
- Turmeric and curcumin safety: a US registry of drug-induced liver injury (a case series) found 10 cases of liver injury from turmeric supplements; 5 people were treated in hospital and 1 died of acute liver failure. The injury usually began 1 to 4 months after starting, 7 of the 10 people carried the gene type HLA-B*35:01, and 3 of the 7 products tested also contained piperine (black pepper), which the authors suggest may be adding to the rise in cases. Stop and see a doctor if your skin or eyes turn yellow, your urine darkens or you feel unusually tired. Turmeric and blood thinners: in one reported case, a person taking fluindione, a blood thinner of the same type as warfarin, had a rise in INR (a measure of how slowly blood clots) while also taking turmeric, and drug-safety specialists judged the interaction probable. Two other single case reports describe unusual bleeding in men taking turmeric or curcumin supplements, one after eyelid surgery and one inside the eye, but neither could prove the supplement caused it. In a randomised placebo-controlled trial in 25 healthy volunteers, turmeric taken for 3 weeks, alone or with aspirin, did not change standard clotting tests or add to aspirin's effect on platelets and caused no significant bleeding, although 5 of 24 people showed weaker platelet clumping in one laboratory test. If you take warfarin or another blood thinner or an antiplatelet drug, or have surgery planned, talk to your doctor before taking turmeric or curcumin.
- Piperine can raise blood levels of medicines. Small studies found more of the epilepsy drugs phenytoin (in 20 patients, after a single 20 mg dose) and carbamazepine (peak up 68.7% and total exposure up 47.9% in 12 volunteers after 10 days of 20 mg a day) in the blood, as well as more propranolol (for blood pressure and the heart) and theophylline (for asthma) in volunteers given 20 mg a day for 7 days, and a peak of the HIV drug nevirapine about 120% higher in 8 healthy men. Check with a pharmacist before starting a product with added piperine if you take regular medicines.
- A review of glutathione and its building blocks, including GlyNAC and N-acetylcysteine, in people with HIV or HIV with tuberculosis found gut discomfort the most common side effect and serious toxicity rare. If you take medicines for HIV, tuberculosis or another long-term condition, tell your doctor before adding either.
Safety note. Talk to a doctor or pharmacist before you start any of these if you take prescription medicines, are pregnant or breastfeeding, or have a long-term health condition. Supplements can interact with medicines.
Shop this protocol
We may earn a commission from these links, at no cost to you. Disclosures
Where to buy · affiliate links
- ThorneCopper BisglycinateBuy on Thorne
Not graded
Copper: NIH's Office of Dietary Supplements (ODS) says: Yes, copper can be harmful if you get too much. Getting too much copper on a regular basis can cause liver damage, abdominal pain, cramps, nausea, diarrhea, and vomiting. Copper toxicity is rare in healthy individuals. However, it can occur in people with Wilson’s disease, a rare genetic disorder. Tell your doctor, pharmacist, and other health care providers about any dietary supplements and prescription or over-the-counter medicines you take.
- iHerbSource Naturals BioPerine, 10 mg, 120 TabletsBuy on iHerb
Grade C
No official safety summary is available for this supplement. If you take prescription medicines, are pregnant or breastfeeding, or have a long-term condition, check with a pharmacist before starting.
Prices and stock are on the retailer's page.
Links to Thorne, Fullscript or iHerb carry our referral, so we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Grades come from the research and never change based on what we earn. Fullscript asks for a free account before it shows its catalog and prices. Full disclosure